By the summer of 2012, the Berrien House had been abandoned for several decades. The structure was collapsing inside with floors sloping severely. Rain cascaded through the roof.
After attempts in the 2000s by several different owners to restore the house, it ended up as a foreclosure property.
Fortunately the bank holding the property, Queensborough National Bank and Trust, understood its historic significance, eventually selling it to Andrew Berrien Jones, descendant.
The new owner decided to return the Berrien House to its period of significance, the second quarter of the 19th century, when John Macpherson Berrien entertained many of his illustrious colleagues here.
That decision required removal of the 1916 stucco, revealing the beaded cypress clapboard of the original structure.
Returning the building to its period of significance also required demolition of the 1916 storefront and lowering the entire structure 3 feet onto a proper 18th century style ground floor.
This image shows the building during the process.
By early 2016, work on the facade had finished.